Ontario’s communities depend on mineral aggregate resources every day. From roads and housing to hospitals, schools, and essential infrastructure, sand, gravel, and crushed stone are fundamental to the province’s continued growth.
As demand for construction materials continues, protecting aggregate resources and ensuring their responsible development are increasingly important. For landowners and businesses considering a new pit or quarry, understanding the planning framework, approval requirements, and technical studies involved is an essential first step.
Why Are Pits and Quarries Important?
Mineral aggregates are essential materials used in concrete, asphalt, road construction, building foundations, drainage systems, and other infrastructure. Their availability directly supports residential development, economic growth, and public infrastructure investment.
The Greater Toronto Area (GTA) consumes approximately one-third of the aggregate used in Ontario each year. Despite relatively consistent demand since 1991, the licensing of replacement reserves has not necessarily kept pace with consumption, highlighting the importance of protecting existing resources and identifying suitable opportunities for future extraction.
Aggregate resources are geographically constrained. Sand, gravel, and suitable bedrock can only be extracted where deposits occur, making location an important consideration. Ensuring that suitable resources are available reasonably close to the markets they serve can help reduce transportation distances and support the efficient delivery of construction materials.
Ontario’s planning framework recognizes this need. The Provincial Planning Statement, 2024 (PPS) directs that mineral aggregate resources be protected for long-term use and, where provincial information is available, identified. It also directs that as much of the resource as is realistically possible be made available as close to markets as possible.
However, identifying an aggregate resource does not automatically permit extraction. A proposed operation must still demonstrate that it can appropriately address land use compatibility, environmental considerations, public health and safety, transportation, and rehabilitation.
Pits and Quarries: What Is the Difference?
Although often discussed together, pits and quarries generally involve different types of resources and extraction methods.
- Sand and gravel pits extract unconsolidated deposits used in concrete, asphalt, road construction, drainage, and general construction.
- Bedrock quarries extract consolidated rock, typically using drilling, blasting, and crushing to produce materials such as concrete stone, asphalt stone, manufactured sand, and other construction products.
The type of deposit influences the extraction method, processing requirements, technical investigations, and site design. Understanding the resource’s quality, extent, and characteristics is therefore an important part of determining whether a property is suitable for aggregate development.
The Role of Recycling and Resource Conservation
Recycling is also an important part of Ontario’s approach to managing aggregate resources. Recovered concrete and asphalt, along with certain suitable construction materials and industrial by-products, can be processed and reused as alternatives to newly extracted aggregate.
Recycled materials are particularly relevant to road construction, where they can reduce waste and supplement the supply of primary aggregate. However, recycled materials cannot replace newly extracted resources in every application because availability and technical specifications vary.
Recycling and responsible extraction should therefore be viewed as complementary approaches to meeting Ontario’s long-term construction needs.
What Is Required to Establish a New Pit or Quarry?
The approval process depends on the property’s location, existing planning permissions, type of aggregate, proposed extraction methods, and applicable legislation. In many cases, a new operation requires municipal planning approvals and a licence under Ontario’s Aggregate Resources Act (ARA).
1. Preliminary Property Review and Pre-Consultation
The first step is to assess the property’s potential for aggregate extraction and identify any planning or physical constraints.
A preliminary review typically considers:
- Official Plan designations and policies, and existing zoning permissions.
- Provincial and municipal aggregate resource mapping.
- Natural heritage features, water resources, and agricultural considerations.
- Surrounding land uses and potential compatibility issues.
- Property access, haul routes, and transportation considerations.
- Site characteristics, including topography, vegetation, and potential extraction areas.
Early consultation with the municipality and relevant authorities can help confirm the likely approval pathway, identify submission requirements, and establish the scope of technical studies.
This preliminary work is valuable because a property may contain an aggregate resource but still face planning, environmental, or operational constraints that influence its suitability for extraction.
2. Municipal Planning Approvals
Where existing permissions do not allow the proposed operation, amendments under the Planning Act may be required.
Official Plan Amendment (OPA): An amendment may be needed where the existing Official Plan designation or policies do not permit aggregate extraction.
Zoning By-law Amendment (ZBA): An amendment may be required to establish appropriate zoning permissions for extraction and associated activities.
Whether one or both amendments are necessary depends on the property’s existing planning framework. Applications may involve technical submissions, agency circulation, public consultation, and consideration by municipal staff and decision-makers.
A planning application must establish that the proposal is appropriate within its broader land use context and addresses applicable provincial and municipal policies.
3. Technical Studies and Supporting Documentation
Technical studies help establish the characteristics of the property, evaluate potential impacts, and identify appropriate mitigation measures. The required studies are site-specific and should be confirmed through pre-consultation with the applicable authorities.
Common requirements may include:
- Planning Justification Report: Evaluates the proposal against applicable provincial and municipal planning policies.
- Aggregate Site Plans: Illustrate existing conditions, extraction areas, processing facilities, access, setbacks, operations, and rehabilitation.
- Geological and/or Geotechnical Assessment: Evaluates the aggregate resource, its suitability for extraction, and relevant site conditions, as required based on the type of aggregate and proposed operation.
- Hydrogeological Assessment: Evaluates groundwater conditions and potential effects on nearby wells and water resources.
- Natural Heritage Assessment or Environmental Impact Study: Assesses natural heritage features and potential ecological impacts.
- Agricultural Impact Assessment: Where applicable, evaluates potential effects on agricultural lands and operations.
- Noise and Blasting Assessments: Evaluate operational noise and, where blasting is proposed, potential effects on nearby properties and structures.
- Traffic Impact Study: Reviews truck movements, site access, haul routes, and road capacity.
- Stormwater Management and Air Quality Assessments: Address drainage, erosion, sediment control, dust, and other relevant operational effects.
- Archaeological Assessment and Surveys: Where required, identify archaeological considerations and establish accurate property boundaries, elevations, and site conditions.
Additional studies may be required depending on the property and proposed operation. Coordinating these assessments is important to ensure that the site design, technical findings, and proposed mitigation measures are consistent.
4. Aggregate Resources Act Licence
Where the ARA applies, a licence is generally required to establish and operate a new pit or quarry, subject to the applicable legislation and exceptions.
The licensing process addresses matters including the proposed extraction operation, environmental considerations, surrounding land uses, water resources, haulage, and rehabilitation. Applications typically require site plans and supporting technical documentation prepared in accordance with applicable provincial requirements.
The site plans establish how the operation will function, including extraction limits, processing and stockpiling areas, access, operational setbacks, water management, and rehabilitation.
Municipal planning approvals and an ARA licence serve different purposes. Where both are required, they must be coordinated to ensure that the proposed operation is consistent with the applicable planning permissions and licensing requirements.
5. Public Consultation and Agency Review
Municipal staff, provincial authorities, conservation authorities, neighbouring landowners, and members of the public may have opportunities to review and comment on a proposal.
Common concerns include truck traffic, noise, blasting, dust, groundwater, natural heritage, agricultural impacts, and the future use of the property.
A well-prepared application should identify these potential concerns and demonstrate how they have been evaluated. Appropriate site design, technical studies, operational measures, and mitigation can help address issues raised during the review process.
Rehabilitation: Planning for the Future
Rehabilitation is a fundamental component of responsible aggregate development. Although extraction may occur over many years, it is generally considered an interim land use, and the future condition of the property must be considered from the outset.
The PPS requires progressive and final rehabilitation to accommodate subsequent land uses, promote compatibility with surrounding uses, recognize the interim nature of extraction, and mitigate negative impacts to the extent possible. It also encourages comprehensive rehabilitation planning where aggregate operations are concentrated in one area.
Progressive rehabilitation involves restoring portions of the property as extraction advances, where feasible. This can help reduce the area of land disturbed at any one time.
Final rehabilitation addresses the remaining disturbed areas after extraction ends. Depending on the property, surrounding land uses, and applicable approvals, rehabilitation may support agricultural uses, naturalized areas, open space, or other compatible future uses.
Rehabilitation should therefore be integrated into the extraction plan and site design from the beginning, rather than treated solely as an end-of-operation requirement.
How Morgan Planning & Development Inc. Can Help
Morgan Planning & Development Inc. provides land use planning and development consulting services to support clients through the planning and approvals process for proposed pits and quarries.
Our services may include:
- Preliminary property and planning policy reviews.
- Planning strategy and pre-consultation coordination.
- Official Plan Amendments and Zoning By-law Amendments.
- Planning Justification Reports and supporting documentation.
- Coordination of planning and technical components of ARA licence applications.
- Agency consultation and responses to review comments.
- Coordination of rehabilitation planning and future land use considerations.
Every property presents its own opportunities and constraints. Our approach is to identify the applicable planning requirements, coordinate the necessary technical work, and establish a practical strategy for advancing the proposal through the relevant approval processes.
Considering a Pit or Quarry?
Ontario’s need for aggregate resources makes the protection and responsible development of suitable deposits an important part of supporting housing, infrastructure, and economic growth. At the same time, successful aggregate development requires careful site selection, technical assessment, appropriate approvals, and a clear rehabilitation strategy.
For landowners, developers, and businesses considering a new pit or quarry, an early planning review can help determine whether a property may be suitable, what approvals may be required, and what studies should be considered before proceeding.
Morgan Planning & Development Inc. can help you understand the planning process and identify a practical path forward for your proposed aggregate operation. Contact our team to discuss your property and the planning requirements that may apply.
Selected Resources
- Provincial Planning Statement, 2024
- State of the Aggregate Resource in Ontario Study
- Aggregate Resources Study – Ontario
- OSSGA – What Is Aggregate Used For?
- Aggregate Resources of Ontario: Combined Standards
- Aggregate Resources Act
- Aggregate Resources Policies and Procedures
- Ontario Geological Survey – GeologyOntario